baby carrier

Are Baby Carriers Bad for Babies?

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    Carriers for infants are convenient for parents to use when they need to carry their children for short distances or on rare occasions. A baby carrier is not likely to have an influence on hip growth, according to the International Hip Dysplasia Institute.

    In contrast, there really is evidence that long periods of time spent in a parent's arms over the first five months of a baby's life, whether for bonding or newborn care, are likely to impact hip development.

    The goal of this informative statement is to help parents make informed decisions about the newborn equipment their children use by providing information regarding hip development to manufacturers. Parents and carers should prioritise the health of their child's hips while making their baby carrier selection. Hips should be let to widen apart, thighs supported, and hips bowed when carrying a baby, especially for extended periods of time.

    Babywearing has advantages for both parents and infants, but it is crucial to use baby backpacks safely, as with any other baby product.

    Whether you're an experienced babywearer or an expectant parent just thinking about it, you'll find all you need to know about babywearing safety right here.

    Babywearing, as you may already know, has several benefits. It's helpful if you have well over one child, if you're a parent and you need to get some work done around the house before you can make dinner, if you're venturing out for the first time to the store or the airport, and if you're planning to do anything requiring you to be hands-free, like cooking.

    Plus, if your newborn is cranky or suffering from reflux, you might find that wearing them in a baby carrier helps. When you wear your baby on the front, he can feel your every move, and it's like a massage in his belly. It has the potential to alleviate the symptoms of colic.

    The newborn remembers your every move and hears your heartbeat from before he was born. Because of this, babywearing can be quite comforting for the infant; it can remind him of how he felt while in your belly for those nine precious months. The temperature of a newborn can be kept more stable with its aid.

    The intimacy, security, and love that is shared between a carer and their infant is just one more emotional advantage of babywearing.

    All of that is appealing, but in order for babywearing to benefit both you and your child, a little amount of preparation and experience is necessary. Babywearing is safe, convenient, and pleasurable for both you and your child only if you follow the guidelines set forth by the manufacturers of baby carriers.

    My Baby Nursery has the biggest range of the best baby clothing. Check it out here.

    Baby Slings Throughout History

    Many cultures have used baby carriers for hundreds of years. Before the turn of the twentieth century, parents all across the world wrapped their infants in shawls, scarves, and even bedsheets so they could get things done while still cuddling their little ones. Unlike how it is viewed in the West now, babywearing was a need, not a novelty. Because mum was so busy, baby had to go along for the ride rather than be the centre of attention. Traditional forms of carrier are all still widely used in the world's poorest countries. However, this is typically only seen in indigenous tribes where carrying infants is considered natural, essential, and part of the cultural norm.

    The British prehistorian Timothy Taylor of Bradford University writes in his book The Artificial Ape that the development of the baby sling allowed for a significant rise in brain size. He claims that the invention of the baby sling made it possible for physically and cognitively stunted children to thrive and grow into healthy adults. What this means is that he concludes that the effort required to develop a large brain slows down overall development.

    Caring for slightly quicker, immature kids was difficult, uneconomical, and often deadly until the advent of the baby sling, which Dr. Taylor dates to at around 2.2 millions of years ago, when the head size of our ancestor abruptly began to expand. Women without baby slings were more likely to be attacked by animals or other people.

    Baby Carrier Dangers 

    baby carrier

    "C-Shaping" a Baby.

    According to Raspa, the first thing to look out for in a well-fitting car seat is that the child isn't crammed in with their chin touching their chest. There is a danger of suffocation if one were to find themselves in such a position. He advises against doing "anything that might prevent the infant from breathing." Keep an eye out for colour changes as you carry your child and be aware of any wriggling. His opinion is that both should be taken seriously as red flags. The more legroom your child has, the better.

    Tightening the Straps on a Baby Too Much

    There are risks associated with either squeezing or holding your child in a way that prevents him or her from breathing, or both. After making sure your child isn't being squished into a C-shape, double-check to make sure he or she isn't being pressed against your neck or back, where asphyxia is also a possibility. Similar red flags to those mentioned in the previous point exist here.

    Leaving Temperature Out Of The Calculation

    As long as you have a snug sling, young baby should be comfortable in the summer sun: Babies have the ability to significantly increase their internal body temperature. Two degrees are not a problem. Having unobstructed movement and breathing space is obviously crucial. However, if your infant is red and perspiring heavily, it's time to take him or her out of the sun and into the shade.

    Allowing the baby to hang straight with their legs down

    To prevent the natural lay flat open from the groyne that occurs when a child's knees are drawn up, we want the baby's hips to remain in a 'W'-shaped position near to their stomachs. The child's butt should be brought towards the belly, and the child's legs should be bent and allowed to fall open. Your baby is at increased risk having hip dysplasia, a deformity of the socket joint, if his or her legs drop straight down at the hips. If you're going to use a wrap, look for that has a wide base and can accommodate your child's weight all the way to the backs of your knees.

    Hip Dysplasia: a “silent Condition” That Can Be Missed

    While paediatricians are able to detect hip dysplasia in infants around 95% of the time, "there are clearly some who fall through the safety nett of inspection," which is one of the reasons why there are contradicting messages about baby carriers.

    Hip dysplasia is a "silent condition," according to IDHI, because affected infants typically do not experience pain and can still master the skills necessary to walk. Whether the hip issues were there at birth and unnoticed, or whether they were acquired later in life, may never be known.

    Signs of hip dysplasia include asymmetry in the buttock creases, audible clicks or pops when the hips are examined, a restricted range of motion when the hips are spread, swayback, and an exaggerated strolling limp or leg length discrepancy when first learning to walk. If parents have concerns, they should talk to a physician.

    Over two years old, discomfort, waddling, and weakness are more likely to develop if treatment for hip dysplasia is delayed. Hip abnormalities and osteoarthritis can appear in young adulthood if they aren't corrected.

    Hip dysplasia affects one in 100 newborns and causes treatment, whereas hip instability affects one in ten newborns. Most cases of hip instability in neonates improve on their own, without the development of dysplasia. Eighty percent of hip dysplasia instances involve females, and when there is a history of the disorder, the risk of hip dysplasia in a baby increases by a factor of 12.

    Tips for Safe Baby Carrying to Reduce the Risk of Non-Congenital Hip Dysplasia

    Hip dysplasia and dislocation are more likely to occur in the months following a baby's birth because of the natural loosening of the baby's joints. In the case of breech births, additional time may be required. The "ball" of a ball-and-socket hip joint can become loose as a result of the natural stretching that happens during birth. According to the International Hip Dysplasia Institute (IHDI), hip dysplasia can occur if a baby's hips are pushed into an abnormally straight and extended position.

    That's why it's important to know the difference between safe and unsafe methods of baby carrying.

    Relatively brief (up to 2 hours) carrying practises pose no risk if your child has healthy hips.

    The problem is that we can't (always) tell if their hips are healthy.

    However, the Navajo nation had a 30% prevalence of hip dysplasia when they firmly swaddled their children on papoose boards. This is because the Navajo people carried their babies for long periods of time each day with their legs straight and tight.

    When a baby is being carried, they should have their hips spread out naturally, to each side of the carrier or caregiver's torso, with their knees and hips bent and their thighs supported. Avoid locking your hips and instead let them move freely.

    Caregivers are urged by the IDHI to use infant carriers that allow for proper hip placement. It concludes that these items are beneficial to one's hip health.

    It's no surprise that good routines for the hips would include things like exercise, a balanced diet, and plenty of sleep. Although we should strive towards these ends, we shouldn't be too hard on oneself if we fall short on any one day.

    The Difference Between a Healthier Hip Position

    Price claims that hip development is optimal during the first six months of a newborn's life when the baby is carried in an inward facing position, towards the face of the carer, rather than outward facing, away from the carer.

    Price noted that experts don't know anything about the danger of intermediate postures for the newborn, such as those in which the baby's legs are bent at an angle rather than straight.

    There may be excellent cause to be a little extra cautious when carrying if your kid has risk characteristics, is loose-jointed and was in a supine position, or if there are risk factors in the family.

    My Baby Nursery has a wide range of the best baby prams for you to choose from.

    Basic Safety Rules for Babywearing

    baby carrier 2

    There are a few universal guidelines that apply to all baby carriers, whether you're using a wrap, ring slings, lian, soft structured carrier, or something else entirely.

    The British Association of Babywearing Instructors developed the TICKS Rule for Safe Babywearing checklist. This aids in the memorisation of precautionary measures.

    Any infant carrier, regardless of age or size, must adhere to the TICKS Rules.

    Babywearing International has also developed a handy A-B checklist. You may find more information about safety guidelines and helpful illustrations of how to put the child in such a carrier on their website.

    A - AIRWAY - Make sure the baby's respiration is being closely watched while in the carrier. Keep the infant's airway clear at all times. If the baby is sitting up, it's much simpler. The baby's chin must be lifted off the chest (a finger or two must fit beneath the chin). Nothing should be covering the baby's nose or mouth, and the baby's face should be open to the air. The infant's face should always be in plain sight. In addition, the baby 's head should have been near your chin, allowing you to kiss it by simply bending forwards.

    The baby's neck and back should be properly supported by the carrier. The infant's knees must be higher than his or her feet, the legs should really be split out in a M shape, and the carriers should keep the baby from slouching. A child's weight should be supported by their thighs and bottom. Young children should ideally be carried upright. Try the cradle or diagonal position when nursing in a carrier, but get back to the upright location as soon as you're done. It is more relaxing for the wearer if the carriers allows the infant to rest in a normal, ergonomic position.

    Always keep in mind that you and your baby's comfort should come first when selecting a carrier. Keep a spotter close by in case we need assistance if you aren't sure you can trust your carrier.

    Furthermore, it is important to regularly inspect your baby carrier for any symptoms of damage or wear, such as worn fabric or loose sewing, which could compromise its safety. Observing such issues may need a call to the maker.

    If you've never used a baby carrier before, it's best to get some practise with a friend or family member who can act as a spotter while you figure out how to use it properly. It's crucial when using a back carrier or a wrap, both of which necessitate learning how to tie a secure knot.

    Ergonomic Position: Frog Position

    Many parents wonder if there is any risk to their child's hip development from using a baby carrier. In fact, the solution is fairly straightforward: correct infant carrying promotes healthy hip development and may even protect against hip dysplasia and dislocation.

    A natural next question is how to carry an infant safely. The hips should be positioned in such a way that they will develop normally without any artificial assistance.

    In the first few months, the frog position, spread-squat posture, straddle position, or jockey position is recommended by the International Hip Dysplasia Institute as the safest way to carry a baby in a carrier

    The hips of the baby fall or spread to the side, the knees and hips bend, and the thighs are stabilized. You can move your hips freely. Additionally, it is not healthy to squeeze the hips together. It's a great position for promoting healthy hip growth. During the first six months of your baby's life, this is the ideal carrying posture

    The legs of the baby should be arranged in a M shape. Whether they're on the inside or the outside of the carrier, their legs should be elevated over their bottoms. The baby's arms should initially be tucked inside the carrier before being moved out once the child masters the ability to control the movement of their neck.

    The infant's back, meanwhile, has to have a healthy rounded shape. If the baby's carrier requires him to straighten his spine, you're doing it wrong. The infant's ability to regulate his neck and spine strengthens organically as he grows.

    The back panel should be the right height and provide the right amount of support for the baby's age.

    When worn correctly, a baby carrier allows an infant to stay in a secure, natural position:

    • Lean forwards, bending at the hips and knees
    • Knees should be greater than or equal to hip level.
    • Initially, the straddle ought to be at about 60 degrees and should be raised to 90 degrees as the infant gets older.
    • To wear a baby, the wearer should position the infant such that the baby's feet face outward, creating a C-shaped spine, and the baby's head should rest on the wearer's chest. The wrap/sling/carrier performs a great job of supporting the complete spine, which means that the weight of the baby's head doesn't put any undue stress on his spinal cord.

    Do not attempt to force the baby's spine, hips, & knees into a straight position before they are ready.

    Some baby carriers or other gear may prevent babies from sitting with their hips in a neutral position. Baby slings, wraps, and carriers are only some examples of this type of gear. Using these for extended amounts of time may force your hips into an unnatural position. Any infant product that forces the legs into an unnatural position should be regarded a possible cause of hip dislocation. To ensure the baby's hips remain in a good situation throughout transport, it is also vital to determine the baby's size and select a device and carrier accordingly.

    It is important for parents to learn about the potential hazards of any gadget their children might use. When in doubt, consult your primary care physician before making any additional choices that could have a medical impact.

    Looking for the best tables and chairs for baby playroom? Look no further. My Baby Nursery has you covered.


    The International Hip Dysplasia Institute concludes that using a baby carrier is unlikely to affect hip development. A baby's hips may be affected by the amount of time spent in a parent's arms during the first five months of life. When carrying a baby, it's best to let your hips open up and bow your thighs. Parents all across the world used to keep their babies close by wrapping them in shawls, scarves, and even bedsheets before the turn of the century. Having babies carried around in slings has led to a sizeable increase in brain volume.

    Squeezing or hugging your child in a way that prevents him or her from breathing can be dangerous. Having the ability to move around freely and breathe easily is, needless to say, a must. Take your baby indoors if he or she is red and sweating profusely. Hip dysplasia is detectable in neonates 95% of the time by paediatricians. The condition does not cause pain for most babies, and they can still learn to walk.

    Young adults can develop hip deformities and osteoarthritis if they aren't treated. Swaddling infants on papoose boards was associated with a 30% increase in hip dysplasia in the Navajo Nation. This is because when they carried their baby, their legs were kept straight and tight. The Newborn Safe Sleep Initiative (IDHI) recommends that carers utilise infant carriers that support healthy hip positioning. Infant's knees should be higher than his or her feet, and his or her chin should be elevated off the chest (about a finger's width of space should be left beneath the chin).

    Carrying a newborn properly can prevent hip dysplasia and dislocation and encourage healthy hip growth. The frog position is the safest way to wear a newborn in a carrier for the first few months. The Jockey Position is recommended by the International Hip Dysplasia Institute. It helps the baby's hips develop properly and provides back support. When used properly, a baby carrier will keep your child in a safe and comfortable position.

    The baby's age will determine the optimal height of the back panel, which should give adequate support. Babies may not be able to maintain a comfortable hip-neutral sitting position when using certain baby carriers and other equipment.

    Content Summary

    • The International Hip Dysplasia Institute concludes that using a baby carrier is unlikely to affect hip development.
    • However, there is solid proof that a baby's hip development is likely to be affected by prolonged lengths of time spent in a parent's arms during the first five months of life, whether for bonding or infant care.
    • In addition, if your infant is fussy or has reflux, you could discover that carrying them in a baby carrier alleviates their discomfort.
    • If you and your baby follow the instructions provided by the carrier's manufacturer, babywearing will be safe, practical, and enjoyable for you both.
    • Bracelets that hold infants Always and Forever Babywearing has a long and rich history across many cultures.
    • When shopping for a car seat, Raspa recommends making sure the youngster is not squeezed in so tightly that their chin touches their chest.
    • According to IDHI, newborns with hip dysplasia do not often experience pain and can still master the skills essential to walk, hence the condition is considered "silent."
    • One in 100 newborns is diagnosed with hip dysplasia, which requires treatment, while one in 10 newborns experiences hip instability.
    • This is because Navajo mothers traditionally held their infants in a tight, straight position for lengthy periods of time each day.
    • Don't hold your hips in a fixed position; instead, allow them to move naturally.
    • Don't let anything get in the way of the baby's airway.
    • The International Hip Dysplasia Institute recommends the frog position, spread-squat posture, straddle position, or jockey position when carrying a baby in a carrier in the first few months.
    • There is a splaying or falling apart of the baby's hips, a bending of the knees and hips, and a stabilisation of the thighs.
    • You have complete freedom of movement in your hips.
    • This is a fantastic posture for encouraging strong hip development.
    • You should always carry your kid in this position for the first six months of his or her existence.
    • Meanwhile, the baby's back has to be spherical for optimal health.
    • The baby's age will determine the optimal height of the back panel, which should give adequate support.
    • Babies may not be able to maintain a comfortable hip-neutral sitting position when using certain baby carriers and other equipment.
    • Determining the baby's size and choosing a device and carrier suitably are other important ways to keep the baby's hips in a healthy position while being transported.

    FAQs About Baby Carrier

    Look for broad, padded shoulder straps that go across your back, as well as a broad waist strap. These will help to distribute your baby's weight evenly and keep some pressure off your shoulders. They should also stop the carrier moving from side to side too much

    The average carrier should last you until 2 years old give or take depending on your baby. After this point, you could upgrade to a large toddler carrier that supports a growing toddler! With these you can carry to 4 years old+.

    Some parents think they can't use a baby carrier until their baby is 6 weeks old or older, or they choose to wait until then. But you can take a baby carrier with you to the hospital and use it the day your baby is born, as long as they weigh at least seven (7) pounds.

    She recommends limiting periods in the carrier to an hour at a time. Then, give your baby a break so that their hips can move around and avoid getting overextended.

    They feel safe and secure by the warmth and familiar scent of their mom. So it only makes sense that your baby wants to be close to you and that they feel safest, and can sleep more soundly, when they're right next to you in a carrier.

    Scroll to Top